I am not surprised to read bad reviews about this restaurant, because I too, had tasted really bad food here before. And it was on the occasion when I suggested to dine there in an outing. I was a bit embarrassed by the lousy recommendation that I have made back then. :P
Maybe 'inconsistency' is a better word to describe the food here, for all the food were to my liking on my previous visit.
Mushroom Soup (8/10)
There are whole mushroom chunks (not bits) in the soup - quite uncommon for a reasonably priced restaurant like this.
Caesar Salad (7/10)